Skip to main content

#0649: Willa Cather to Edwin Hatfield Anderson, November 24, 1922

More about this letter…
Plain view:

Guide to Reading Letter Transcriptions

Some of these features are only visible when "plain text" is off.

Textual Feature Appearance
passage deleted with a strikethrough mark deleted passage
passage deleted by overwritten added letters overwritten passage
passage added above the line passage with added text above
passage added on the line passage with added text inline
passage added in the margin passage with text added in margin
handwritten addition to a typewritten letter typed passage with added handwritten text
missing or unreadable text missing text noted with "[illegible]"
uncertain transcriptions word[?]
notes written by someone other than Willa Cather Note in another's hand
printed letterhead text printed text
text printed on postcards, envelopes, etc. printed text
text of date and place stamps stamped text
passage written by Cather on separate enclosure. written text
NUMBER FIVE BANK STREET3 My dear Mr. Anderson1:

I am just hurrying off for the West to spend Thanksgiving with my mother4 and father5, but I will try to answer your questions briefly.

1. There was a Georgine Milmine6, now Mrs. Benjamin Wells, of Aubrey, New York7, a Canadian newspaper woman, who spent years in getting together a great deal of material relating to Mrs. Eddy8's life and the history of Christian Science.

2. Mr. McClure9 bought her material and notes. There was an enormous amount of it; cuttings from newspapers of forty years ago, court records, early editions of "Science and Health"10 now absolutely unobtainable. It was a splendid collection of material and after Mr. McClure sold the magazine11 to a perfectly irresponsible young man named Collins12, this was all scattered and lost--a first edition of "Science and Health" thrown away with junk.

3. From the first, Miss Milmine admitted that she hadn't sufficient technical ability to combine all her evidence and produce a biography. Mr. McClure tried out three or four13 people at writing the story. It was a sort of competition. He liked my version the best chiefly because it was unprejudiced--I haven't the slightest bone to pick with Christian Science. This was when I first came to New York2, and that piece of writing was the first important piece of work I did for magazines. After I finished it, I became Managing Editor.

4. A great deal of time and money were spent on authenticating all the material, in it used, and with the exception of the first chapter, I think the whole history14 is as authentic and accurate as human performances ever are. All the letters and documents quoted are absolutely authentic, and in every case, we either had or personally copied the original documents--the first chapter, however, I did not write. It was written by Burton J. Hendrick, who has now an important position with Doubleday15. Mr. Hendrick was very much annoyed at being called off the job and never forgave Mr. McClure. Hendrick is an accurate writer, but much of the first chapter--especially the first part of itfrankly deals with legend--with what envious people and jealous relatives remember of Mrs. Eddy's early youth. It was given for what it was worth, but I always consider such sources dubious.

NUMBER FIVE BANK STREET

5. Undoubtedly, Doubleday has perfectly good business reasons for keeping the book16 out of print. There has been a great demand for it to which he has been consistently blank. You see nobody took any interest in its fate. I wrote it myself as a sort of discipline, an exercise. I wouldn't fight for it; it's not the least in my line. Miss Milmine, now Mrs. Wells, is in the awkward position of having her name attached to a book, of which she didn't write a word. I am only sorry that the splendid collection of material, from which the story was written, was lost and destroyed.

Now this is absolutely confidential, Mr. Anderson. I have never made a statement about it before, in writing or otherwise. I suppose somebody ought to know the actual truth of the matter and so long as I am writing to you about it, I might as well ask you to be the repository of these facts. I know, of course, that you want them for some perfectly good use, and will keep my name out of it.

Wit my heartiest greetings to Mrs. Anderson17 and yourself, I am

Faithfully yours Willa Cather