Skip to main content

#3269: Sarah J. Bloom on behalf of Willa Cather to Edward Wagenknecht, October 20, 1944

More about this letter…
Plain view:

Guide to Reading Letter Transcriptions

Some of these features are only visible when "plain text" is off.

Textual Feature Appearance
passage deleted with a strikethrough mark deleted passage
passage deleted by overwritten added letters overwritten passage
passage added above the line passage with added text above
passage added on the line passage with added text inline
passage added in the margin passage with text added in margin
handwritten addition to a typewritten letter typed passage with added handwritten text
missing or unreadable text missing text noted with "[illegible]"
uncertain transcriptions word[?]
notes written by someone other than Willa Cather Note in another's hand
printed letterhead text printed text
text printed on postcards, envelopes, etc. printed text
text of date and place stamps stamped text
passage written by Cather on separate enclosure. written text
Dear Dr. Wagenknecht1:

I appreciate your kindness in sending me the chapter on Miss Cather3. I have been her secretary longer than either Miss Cather or I would care to admit, and I know the history of most of her books.

As you have said, Miss Cather did write Mr. McClure4's autobiography5. The method she pursued was rather interesting. Once a week Mr. McClure came to Miss Cather's apartment, sat down, and said, "Now, where did I stop last time?" and then resumed his story where he had left off the week before. He was perfectly at ease with Miss Cather because she had worked with him for several years as managing editor6 of his magazine7. He simply remembered out loud. Miss Cather doesn't know shorthand. The next day she began writing it out in longhand. Then I used to copy it8 for her on the typewriter. She said it was very good practice in writing "conversation" exactly as she had heard it. All of Mr. McClure's characteristic phrases staid in her mind.

Your reference to Miss Cather's part in The Life of Mary Baker G. Eddy9, however, is rather misleading. The author of the book, Georgine Milmine10, (that was her maiden name) was the wife of Benjamin Wells11, a newspaper man in Rochester, N.Y.12 Miss Cather never saw the manuscript until the first number of the serial13 came out in McClure's. Unfortunately, someone had palmed off on Mrs. Wells a photograph purported to be a picture of Mrs. Eddy as a young woman. It was not Mrs. Eddy at all, but the photograph of one of her early disciples. This inaccuracy, of course, brought a good deal of discredit on the whole series of articles which was to follow. Miss Cather was then Mr. McClure's managing editor, and he sent her at once to Boston14, to spend some months there. She was sent to check up the facts stated by Mrs. Wells, and to consult such as were living of Mrs. Eddy's early pupils and followers. Her work was strictly editorial.

I might call your attention to another minor matter. In the month of March, three months after Miss Cather was eight years old15, her father16 removed his family to Nebraska17. Miss Cather always says that she was transplanted to Nebraska when she was eight years old, since she was much nearer eight than nine.

With regard to your last paragraph, you courteously ask me if I could make any further suggestions. You begin by mentioned a book18 by a Swiss, Reneé Rapin19. The man never saw Miss Cather — I think he never came to this country20 at all. He sent her a questionnaire of two or three hundred questions. They were so foolish that she positively declined to answer them, and to all his later appeals she would have nothing to say. I never myself saw it, but I understand that there is scarcely a correct fact in the book.

I wonder whether you have seen the sketch of Miss Cather in the fourteenth edition of the Encyclopaedia Britannica21? It seems to me much more interesting than that in the National Encyclopedia22, published by James T. White23. I have not read all the articles you mention in your last paragraph, but since you ask me, I am very glad to suggest several articles by better known writers than some of those you mention.

Carl Van Doren24 Contemporary American Novelists25 Essay Willa Cather Macmillan
Rebecca West26 The Strange Necessity27 Essay The Classic Artist Doubleday, Doran
A. D. Dickinson28 Best Books of Our Time29 Doubleday, Doran (1928)
T. K. Whipple30 Spokesmen31 Essay Willa Cather Appleton
Margaret Lawrence32 The School of Femininity33 Essay Katherine Mansfield, Willa Cather, Virginia Woolf Stokes
Contemporary American Authors34.
edited by J. C. Squire35
Papers from the London Mercury36, Essay Willa Cather Holt

Since Professor Whipple's book was published in 1928, you might find it difficult to get, and I take the liberty of sending you my own copy, thinking it might be of some convenience to you.

Very truly yours, Sarah J. Bloom37Secretary Dr. Edward Wagenknecht 1721 Chancellor Street Evanston, Illinois38